For all its many virtues, it does have a tendency toward sentimentalism. When does a heartfelt sad love song turn to treacle? Sometimes this gets so bad that it makes even Tim McGraw almost impossible to listen to. Plus, he's a Democrat.
The talented but sappy Mr. McGraw
Like talented and deluded Brad Paisley. Well, not everyone is Toby Keith.
I think it leans that way because it is an industry, a business. It publishes music that its demographic wants. Its other flaw, IMHO, is the overdone narrative of the cheatin' man hurtin' the poor lil woman. This allows the part archetypal and part feminist theme of woman-as-victim to paint men as worthless jackasses. Women can react violently to this without consequence.
I was surprised to discover the actual demographics of country music fans. Only a little more than half female. Are the men of country music out to make women like them so they can get...you know?
Prolly.
From my immune-to-female-sex-appeal POV, this always makes me shake my head.
But for melody and instrumentation, narrative, play with language and love of ordinary humanity, it's still pretty damn good American music.
--
*Even contemporary country gets tainted with it now and again, trying to be cool and PC.
-

